When I had my photography business, the "great debate" among photographers was Nikon vs. Canon. Both are great, in their own ways.
But I was never really sold on Nikons. It was just wasn't there for me. It was like being told to date somebody because they checked all the boxes people are supposed to, "but...I don't know. Not feelin' it."
Then a friend talked me into trying Canons. He said "If you buy one, you'll fall in love with it." He was right. I bought one, and I was a goner for Canon. Still am.
Well, now that I've taken up music, there's another "great debate" to deal with: learning music theory.
I decided to study it when I took up guitar because I realized I didn't understand terms like "intervals." I thought guitar was more about learning chords, and technique. But I kept running into these pesky terms I couldn't quite get.
I bit the bullet, and dove in. I'm glad I did. It's been truly useful for me, especially in songwriting. I'm no expert, and never will be. And I don't follow it rigidly. But I needed a framework for music, and music theory gives me one.
Having said that...I would never say "You absolutely must learn music theory." Some musicians don't need it.
There was this British band awhile back whose members didn't know music theory, and they couldn't read music, either.
Oh, what was their name? "Come on, Fortune, think!!"
Oh, YEAH - the Beatles! That's right!!
I think they did okay without it. π
I would recommend you at least try to learn theory. Read a book on it. My beloved Dummies books have some terrific ones.
If it works for you, great. Keep doing it. If you don't need it, don't sweat it.
You're in good company with the lads from Liverpool. π΅πΆπΌπΈ